Best Crib Mattresses Consumer Reports: Reviews And Top 7 Rated

Last updated:

Stepping into the life of parenthood is a feeling that can’t be described in words. Being a parent means that you have a beautiful life around you who is there because of you, and this very thought is good enough to put a decent amount of pressure in your mind. You need to be responsible now or else, you will come across all sorts of troubles.

Babies love to sleep, and as a parent, you need to make sure that when your baby is asleep, there should be a pin-drop silence around him/her. You can buy a baby monitor to keep an eye on your baby while you are in another room doing household work. However, if you could invest in best crib mattress consumer reports after going through reviews of seven best products, then you most probably don’t need anything else because a comfortable mattress will not let your baby wake up in between sleep.

Reviews Of Seven Best Crib Mattresses

1. Colgate Eco Classica III Dual Firmness Orthopedic Style Crib Mattress

best crib mattress consumer reports

Parents look for a soft, anti-allergic and long-lasting crib mattress for their little ones, and this product is exactly that. The mattress is made up of hypoallergenic materials, and since it is a double-sided mattress, the mattress remains firm and cozy.

The mattress features an organic cotton cover, which keeps the mattress protected and your child safe against any allergy and/or skin rashes. The drawbacks of the mattress include sharp smell at the time of taking the product out of its package, single size option, and expensive price.

2. Milliard Crib Mattress Dual Comfort System

best crib mattress consumer reports

This is another excellent crib mattress, which comes with dual firmness, thus it can be used for infants as well as toddlers. The mattress is made from 100% cotton whereas the inner foam is made of polyurethane. The mattress has been approved by all government agencies responsible for checking mattresses in the US. The ‘dual comfort system’ feature enables users to change the firmness of the mattress, depending upon who's laying down on the mattress.

The mattress features a supporting foam layer, which keeps the baby safe, whereas the other side comes with a contouring memory foam that offers support to toddlers. Made with 100% cotton allows this mattress to be breathable and waterproof. This mattress can be easily cleaned in the best stackable washer and dryer unit. Even its cover is water-resistant, so don’t you worry about this product. The only drawback of this mattress is the foul smell that comes once the mattress is taken out of its packaging.

3. Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Dual Sleep Surface Crib Mattress

best crib mattress consumer reports

Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer is a beautiful mattress for babies, which feature a two-stage sleep system, once side of which accommodates infant while other accommodates toddler. For the infant, the layer incorporates organic foam, which is an extra firm. Whereas for toddlers, the layer is soft plush.

The company has used waterproof fabric, which has been properly sewn and is quite durable. A medical-grade fabric, it will have no effect from toxic chemicals. The material of this mattress is made with 100% waterproof material, which is also hypoallergenic. So, your children can enjoy a sound sleep without being bothered by bed bugs and/or dust mites. This mattress is meant to perform excellently for infants as well as for toddlers, so you should definitely consider it.

4. Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed

best crib mattress consumer reports

If your baby is fond of sleep, then you must have a soft and comfortable crib mattress like this one from Newton. This mattress is breathable, courtesy of the quality material it is made up of. The company uses 100% cotton, so you will not find metal springs, polyurethane foam or any adhesive used in this mattress.

The airy design of the mattress allows the baby to sleep comfortably all night. This mattress is immune to bacteria or any other pathogens that usually house mattresses, which is a good thing. As far as cleaning of this mattress is concerned, you can clean it in the washing machine without any issue.

5. Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Mattress 

best crib mattress consumer reports

Another crib mattress for infants and toddlers and this one has a water-resistant inner lining, which keeps babies dry and warm throughout the night. The company is so confident on its mattress that it offers a 6-year warranty as well. You can place this mattress on any size of crib, be it a standard-sized crib or a full-sized one. It can even fit a toddler bed, so full marks to this mattress on versatility.

The mattress is compressed in a small box, which is also lightweight, thus making it easy for users to carry it. After unpacking the mattress, give it at least 48 hours to expand it to its full size. The mattress is made up of a high-quality breathable foam, which lets the airflow to its full potential, thus letting your infant sleep comfortably. On top of the mattress, a water-resistant cover has been placed, which can be easily removed and washed. The mattress is compliant to all government standards for a quality mattress. 

6. Dourxi Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed Mattress

best crib mattress consumer reports

Dourxi crib mattress is another fine product for your infant as well as a toddler. The incredible design of this mattress along with the quality of material used in it makes this mattress very comfortable. The company has used 100% organic cotton, which is not just soft, but totally safe for babies’ skin.

The mattress fits nicely a standard-sized crib, and it is one of the firmest and most durable mattresses you’ll see on the market. The product is CertiPUR certified, which means it is free from phthalates. Even the company offers a 60-day refund along with 10 years of warranty, which shows how excellent this mattress really is.

7. Milliard BCM2 Memory Foam Crib Mattress

best crib mattress consumer reports

This crib mattress is meant to give your child the most comfortable sleep he/she will ever get. The unique design of this mattress allows maximized airflow along with the regulated temperature. On top of that, the cover of the mattress is made from bamboo, which is known for its comfort, plus it makes cleaning the cover easier too. The mattress incorporates a thick layer of memory foam, which keeps the mattress in shape for years to come.

The company has used natural fiberglass lining in the mattress that makes it fire-resistant. Moreover, there has not been any use of chemicals or other toxic substances in the manufacturing of this mattress. You can wash the mattress cover in a washing machine, as it is waterproof and washing machine safe, but make sure to dry it fully before covering the mattress with it.

How To Choose The Best Crib Mattress

The mattress is one of the centerpieces of your child's room. Indeed, for your child to have a good sleep, his bedding must be chosen carefully. To help you choose the mattress, I have made a list of the essentials to look at before buying.

Essential Elements To Take Into Account Before Buying A Mattress

The State

New or used? The temptation is great to use the mattress of the big brother or cousin but it is better to opt for a new mattress that will not be deformed by previous users and which will be especially more hygienic.

The Dimensions:

  • Cot mattress: the dimensions are either 60 x 120 cm or 70 x 140 cm for a rectangular bed of standard shape.
  • Children's mattress: the dimensions are in general 90 x 190/200 cm.

The Density

Prefer a density between 20 and 22Kg/m3. For mattresses with latex core, it will be 55kg/m3. The density is very important for the well being of baby, it is necessary that the maintenance is quite firm. If the density is too low, the heart of the mattress will sag.

Different Mattress Filling Materials

Choose your mattress first according to its lining. Here are the four packings you will find most often:

  • Foam: This is the most common upholstery. It allows a great comfort during the sleep of the child and firm support adapted to its morphology. Also, lighter, the foam mattress will be more manageable when changing sheets.
  • Coconut fiber: An ecological material that will contribute to the well being of your child. The coconut fiber lets air circulate, which prevents the development of moisture and therefore bacteria and mites.
  • Wool: Also very natural, wool is a thermoregulatory and highly insulating material. It allows drying quickly in case of leakage or perspiration. A wool heart mattress will provide baby a great softness.

Different Materials Of The Mattress Envelope

After packing, consider looking at the mattress cover. There are many different materials that can be used as a mattress cover, but here is the list of the most common ones that are being used in most crib mattresses:

  • Bamboo Fiber: Recommended for allergy-sensitive people, bamboo fiber is anti-mite and repels bacteria. Natural material very soft, it is also very absorbent. Be careful this mattress needs to be in an airy room and not wet.
  • Organic Cotton: This material does not charge static electricity, so it allows a great quality of sleep to your child. On the other hand, it should be noted that cotton is less absorbent than other materials.
  • Wool: Very soft, it ensures great comfort to the baby. This 100% natural material dries quickly and ensures the perfect temperature of your child's body.
  • Tencel: 100% natural material, it eliminates moisture thanks to its breathable and absorbent properties. Cool in summer, it will also bring warmth to your child in winter.

Final Verdict

It is confirmed that a crib mattress is the best thing you can get for your baby to ensure that he/she sleeps comfortably. However, which type of crib mattress to buy is a task that I leave up to you because I have reviewed seven of the best crib mattress consumer reports where each product has something unique and exciting to offer. Now, you have to decide as to which crib mattress suits your child in the best way.